Designer Babies: Medical or Cosmetic Epidemic?

Designer babies are definitely a very controversial topic. Depending on who you talk to, you could get different opinions ranging from people who totally support it, to people who are dead set against it. Some people think that it is not okay at all for people to get to choose what qualities their babies will possess, and some people say that if it is beneficial for the parents, or for the child, that it is ok. 

The cost alone of designer babies would be enough to make people think twice about it. Cost ranges from $18,000 and higher in order to receive your “perfect child.” The reasons that people are against designer babies range from more than the cost. For example, some people believe that having a designer baby goes against religious values. They believe that it takes away from God’s authority to create your baby. Also, some people believe that creating designer babies would create more controversy in the world then there already is. An example of controversy that would be created is that it would take away the diversity of our world. There would be more blondes then red heads, and more brunettes then people with black hair, or the opposites of both. Regardless of what hair colour, or eye colour, or body shape, or personality is most requested, there is always going to be a dominance of said characteristics, because people can chose what they want. Also, since designer babies are so expensive, it would create a divide between the rich and poor. The divide would be created because the richer kids would have been able to receive such expensive treatment to make them look a certain way, whereas, the poorer people of the nation would not have been able to afford that and it would result in them having flaws that the richer people don’t have.

On the other hand, there are people who support the creation of designer babies, and provide valid points as to why they have chosen to support this new epidemic. Some people believe that designer babies could be a huge asset to medical enhancement. For example, if there is a child with cancer, and their parents aren’t a match to a transplant they need, a designer baby could be created so that you know the newborn will be a match to the child with cancer. Other cases that designer babies would be beneficial for medical reasons would be to prevent a baby from contracting a disease such as cystic fibrosis, through karymapping. If cystic fibrosis runs in the genes of a family, and the parents know how likely it is that their child will struggle with this disease, they might opt for having a designer baby, so that they know their child will not contract the disease that has been so widespread in their family.

Overall, I think that having a designer baby is really a personal choice, and depends more on the situation than anything else. If parents want to have a designer baby so that it’ll look a certain way, or so that it’ll possess a certain characteristic (i.e. want their children to have height, so they can play a certain sport etc.) then I do not believe it is ok. I do believe that if someone wants a designer baby for medical reasons, then it is ok, depending on the extremes to which they are going to make the child go. Regardless, I do believe that there will always be controversy over designer babies, but it is definitely a personal choice.

http://science.discovery.com/videos/brink-news-designer-babies.html This video demonstrates the divide between babies who have been genetically engineered, and babies who have not.

                                          

SOURCES

http://www.buzzle.com/articles/pros-and-cons-of-designer-babies.html

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/955644.stm

http://articles.cnn.com/2008-10-30/tech/designer.babies_1_genetic-screening-designer-babies-animal-embryos?_s=PM:TECH

Blogs Commented On
Vilma Lopez: http://www.vilmabioblog.blogspot.com/
Melissa Quinn: http://melissasbioblog.blogspot.com/